Huh? I'm not quite understanding your point. My point was that at his peak he was not someone who could defend all five positions well. Garnett was one of the players who could so I used him as an example. Lebron was not. Great player but that phrase never applied to him at any point in his career, imo.
Im sorry. Your last sentence in the previous post was Lebron is/was not.
Lebron of today doesnt play defense so including that Lebron in the discussion is worthless.
You argue that Labron wasnt good at handling bigger players, right? Or at least guarding all 5 well, was Garnett really that guy? I dont recall him shutting down point guards at any point or shadowing a teams best perimeter player for an entire game. He did well in spot duty, as Lebron did when switched at times.
Garnett was a better defender than Lebron.
But was he better at guarding perimeter players than Lebron was at guarding post players? I dont think its that big of a difference.
In my opinion, I think because Lebron is still playing we compare his today to everyones best. Lebron at his best was a very good 1-5 defender. Garnett was a better defender at his peak but that also came when he was no longer the offensive focal point in Boston.
I dont know if there has been any one who could guard all 5 well. Garnett is a good choice but Id also include young Rodman.