Anyone on this board, even that guy who's in wheelchair, would've broken the all-time yard record with the kind of offensive line that Emmitt had.
I'm dead serious.

He'd have had incredible yardage, but there's no proof at all that he had any degree of toughness, that he could move the chains when it counted or sustain possession given his way of running.
That's aside from the fact that he never proved that he was an outstanding playoff performer, while Smith was one of the best backs in playoff history. This can't just be dismissed as irrelevant by extrapolating regular season numbers into the playoffs: some guys just get it done when it counts while Barry didn't prove that at all. Or that he could've played part of a playoff game with a separated shoulder.