This is my final response to this dude.
McKelvin was told to return the ball by the best special teams coach in the NFL for this reason: If he downs it, the Bills were most likely to go 3 and out. They punt. The Pats return it X number of yards. Brady steps in and finishes the game.
They needed yardage period. The mistake was made in reaching out with the ball, trying to get that extra yard. It was correct to return the ball. How can you debate that with the best, if not one of the best speical teams coaches out there? Your ignoance is amazing. Regardless, you're entitled to your opinion.
GO BILLS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great, now "mr. all-state" says I'm ignorant as well as an idiot. You have NO idea if the coach told him that or not, like I said, he is going to defend his player. Ok, if you can comprehend that we will move on to my next point.
You say that I'm an idiot, and ignorant, for debating what "the best special teams coach out there" says, yet you are debating every other football expert that has an opinion on the subject? C'mon, quit being a homer. The guy made a mistake, it's that simple.