Hulkster makes bad analogies , especially using Yates vs Ray & Wheeler as refference to having a big gut , now first let me state Yates' gut was distended and he had a naturally " wide " waist , however in that pic Shawn Ray is about 205lbs and Flex is about 220lbs max , Yates outweighs Ray by 50lbs and Flex by about 37lbs so thats not 100% fair , check out this pic of Yates at 228lbs his waist compares very favorably to Ray & Wheeler at around the same weight.
I've never really been a fan of Cutler's phyisque , Yates does have the edge on calves , I would say triceps , and back , not to mention V-taper , which is clearly evident in the ab-thigh pose , and the latspreads , and Yates has much better balance , and you could break a bodybuilder down part for part but what really matters is how they look in the mandatory poses and in my opinion Yates simply outclasses Cutler.