boy oh boy, lots of reading done...
I would be very surprised if smm were melao... I've spoken to the guy in 2005 regarding some errors in his page and he seems nothing like the sucky...
and he is genuinely intelligent. he has done standardized iq tests, unlike unmonitored self applied tests, like the sigma test.
From the quotes that I've seen regarding IQ, sucky seems to be mimicking the iq of celebrities that is posted in sigma society website.
see the url
http://www.sigmasociety.com/qi/sigma_qi.asp
the part of child iq tests, the extrapolation and all that dubious stuff is there...
for smm to be melao would actually be great for him, despite how he looks.
So... at getbig, the "real" hindemburg melao would be a respected member, because he's smart for real? Even after the videos popped up, it would still be an honor for us to converse with such an intelligent specimen?
Can't you see in the videos that HMJr desperately tries to be a real life badass? He would like to be bruce lee or van damme, if only he could. Following your reasoning, HMJr is a perfectly decent man, that is not in the least bit weird and leads a normal life, but that's not true.
As far as real IQ testing goes: He was critiqued heavily on the cerebrals board, which is a recognized IQ society, by the administrator himself, who claimed that Melao isn't all that he pretends to be. Also, melao's wikipedia page was deleted, because the provided sources were not good enough.
I think it's amazing how people will accept that SMM is obviously Pedro Coderch. Evidence for this are simply excerpts of his writings on marksimpson.com and yahoo that show a similar style of reasoning and opinions that SMM also advocates. I also think that SMM is Pedro Coderch, but IMO these are both pseudonyms, nothing more. What evidence do I have?
THE SAME KIND OF EVIDENCE THAT HAS BEEN USED TO SEE THAT SMM IS PEDRO CODERCH!
The demands have mysteriously been altered

To believe at this point that HMJr is SMM, we need airtight proof, such as "HMJr himself should confess that he's SMM" or "HMJr should be caught saying that he really is SMM from the getbig forums", which will actually never happen, because SMM is a cover name, and it's purpose is... to cover the real identity.
And you have to remember, TA has further evidence... and at this point.... TA IS SUPPORTING THE SMM/MELAO VERSION! Why should he do that?