Without going into specifics about my cock (too dangerous on a board filled with fags), I went from extremely skinny pre-training, to bodybuilder big (relatively speaking here, I was never something that would make someone entrenched in bodybuilding turn around to look) on steroids after years, to now around 200 lbs and very lean after having been off steroids since 2008 or 2009.
My personal experience: most success with women when I was 130 lbs at 6 3, least success at my biggest, to more success than at my biggest but still less than at 130 lbs now. Exactly according to the poll the OP posted, exactly according to what I knew already.
Now this is only personal experience, I wasn't actually talking about personal experience up until now, because then I'd be making the same mistake I accused others of making (thinking that ME is what IS).
I was talking about what I've consistently seen throughout the years. Women like regular bodies the most, sometimes with a preference for the lean six pack variety, but hardly ever for real muscle, let alone a hardcore bodybuilder.
They just don't like all of that muscle. Muscle is man-territory. And yes, both my personal experience as well as what I have seen confirms that homosexuals dig the muscle very much.