for example, someone comes up with a method, say, like galeniko and no ones. the scientific way of proceeding about things would then be to design an experiment and conduct countless trials with as many people as possible, then record and analyze the results, and finally see if they match the expected outcome. if they dont, the method needs to be adjusted.
the "broscience" way is: claim you've found the ultimate fat loss method, tell everyone to go try it, and then, when people report back, if the results aren't what you expected (i.e. resounding success) tell them they screwed up, they are wrong, or invent some other excuse which allows you to continue on believing in your method.
when people forget this and go around preaching their dogma as gospel... things get ugly. just look at the sorry end of the gh15 saga... everyone thought the guy gave great advice, then he starts acting like an infallible "god of hormones" and the next thing you know he's completely alienated everyone.
listen kid. if you have something to say to me say it, instead of beating around the bush like a fucking pansy. i dont deal well with passive/ aggressive as your about to find out. throw bipolar in there too for good measure im thinking. anyway, if you have something to say just say it. its easy- watch and learn:
to your first point. you got hurt feelings cause i called you a retard for thinking that your losing muscle on 1500 cals a day, and pointed out that mayyyyyybe, just maybe you didnt really have all that much muscle to begin with. you see, sunshine, people hold fat in different ways. some hold it where its highly visible. others hold it so that it marbles and gives the appearance of muscle when it is in fact not. thats why when they start losing fat they think they are losing 'muscle'. thats why a lot of permabulkers stay premabulkers. they cannot the simple truth that the reason they deflate so rapidly on any kind of calorie restrictive diet is because the 'muscle' they are carrying is actually fat. and you dont have to be 15-20%bf to have this happen. it can happen at even 8-10%. it doesnt happen much past then cause by the time your 7% you have a pretty good idea what you really look like under all that.
have you stopped to consider that you are too mentally weak to do this diet? or any diet for that matter? you think dieting is easy? if it was everyone would look like gal. but it isnt . its hard work. 'oh nooo i have headaches wah wah wah' lol fucking please. ever stop to think why you've never been in shape in your life is because a) the 'diets' you follow suck, and b) you lack the discipline to stay on them long enough to see any real results?
to your second point. you want to see 'resoundingly' successful results in one week. you lose 10 pounds in 10 days or whatever it is but you think its not enough cause you didnt magically wake up with an 8 pack the day after going on the diet, and holy shit you weight 5 pounds more! your a fucking retard.
to your third point that you dont have the balls to say right out. you think i give a FUCK what you or anyone else on this board thinks of me? think i do this for praise and acclaim? kind gives an insight into the way your mind works when you project stupidity like this onto others. i do this to help people who want help. end of story. not too hold the hand of a little girl like you whos going to get all butthurt when i tell him the straight goods. you come here, tell me bullshit in support of your 'claims' (hahah im loooosing muscle on 1500ca) and get a prolapsed colon when i rebuttal it with the truth. you had a lot of balls implying in your post before this one directed at me (thats what you do-imply- cause you dont have the balls to speak your mind) your doing me a favour by following this diet. here let me help you out with another tip- feel free to take this diet and shove it directly up your ass. see arent i a nice guy- look at all the time i saved you at failing at it.
and a good day to you, sir.
(holy this is some of my best work to date right here

)