As I pointed out above, Yates wins 3 out of 4 of those criteria, however, I still believe it would be a very close battle, as Coleman clearly has the advantage in this regard:
"In assessing prejudging, overall shape and that of the various
muscle groups is important. The judge should favour competitors
with a harmonious, classical physique."
However, I'm really not so sure how closely the judges follow this as Yates defeated many competitors with straight firsts eventhough they had superior overall shape (Ray, Levrone, Sonbaty, Coleman, Wheeler, Dillet, etc).