Dorian Yates kicks Ronnie's ass Hulkster is a punk Bitch and fuck any truce

[nicorulez]

Guys, come on now.  This thread is getting a little long in the tooth.  ND has a set of standards that he adheres to, and in his mind Dorian is better.  Hulkster, Pumpster, and myself feel the opposite.  In reality, with the variability in the IFBB judging, it is conceivable that each bodbybuilder could show up in similar shapes on two different occasions and the outcome would be different.  I am almost feeling ND's plea for a truce.  Really, Hulkster, do you really think after 300 pages you are going to change his mind.  ND, do you think you will convince Hulkster or other Ronnie supporters.  Both make excellent points, but each has to admit that with their respective biases that the viewpoint will always slant toward their guy.  Personally, I loved Ronnie in 2003 as he was the most powerful looking person to ever set foot on stage.  However, I can see how ND likes Dorian circa 1992/1993 as he looked damn good.  Each has their respective strengths and weaknesses.  But really guys, 293 pages and no end in site.  Make a truce; agree to disagree.  Hell, the dems and republicans have been carrying that mantra for hundreds of years.  It is not a crime.  If everybody on this board felt the same way, it would be pretty boring.  I would then rather check out the "So You Think You Can Dance" forums.  BTW, if you watch the show, Allison and Natalie are hot.    Peace all.  Remember, in the end, we are a small group of individuals who need to ultimately support each other, regardless if you agree or not.  Peace.

[suckmymuscle]

  ore shots comparing 1997 Dorian to Ronnie in his 1998 version... By the way, Dorian is killing Ronnie in density there. Let's see Ronnie beat this taper and lat width from the front.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

[Hulkster]

let alone being compared to Dorian in 1995, arguably te best pakage any Mr.Olympia ever brought onstage.

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH AHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

no post tear version of Dorian could compete against the man with history's greatest overall arms...


no way.

[NeoSeminole]

Well, you dimwitted newbie, since the bottom pic you posted is of Dorian at the 1997 Olympia and since that was his worst performance ever, I don't accept any comparison with any of Ronnie's versions other than 2001/4. It is as simple as that.

Ahh, now you are changing your argument. That's not what you said earlier:

By way, these pics are from Dorian in 1997 and he still has a si-pack, a striated lower back and an incredible front lat spread. Too bad Ronnie doesen't look this good at over 270 lbs.

Furthermore, I have already posted several multi-paragraph posts explaining why Ronnie wasn't that great in 2003; if you weren't such a shitty little newbie, both to this thread and to this board as well, you'd know that. I must have written at least 100 paragraphs about this topic and won't do it again, just for your convenience.

No, I read what you said. I have been following this thread since the day it began. You assume the date I first posted here is when I joined this forum. All your multi-paragraph posts are shit. I've read your biased assessments.  I've watched you use morphed pics of Dorian. I've watched you say you have a genius IQ. I've watched you repeatedly own yourself by posting comparisons where Ronnie looks better. I've watched you claim Dorian looked better in 97 than Ronnie in 03. I've also watched you contradict yourself.

I compared Dorian's worst(1997) against one of Ronnie's worst(2004), where Dorian is destroying Ronnie, so I have nothing to prove. I have already posted, pages ago, the 1996 Dorian destroying the 1998 Ronnie in the abs-and-thighs mandatory. Again, you're lost. But then, what can we expect from a newbo?

I'm still waiting.  

Ronnie in 2003 was great muscularity-wise, but he was not great overrall because his midsection was unacceptable and his body was completely unbalanced, especially the lower one.

Ha ha ha ha

[Bear]

You are such a f*cking hypocrite it's not even funny. I scale Dorian and Ronnie within +/- 1 inch of each other in every comparison. Here are your "brilliant" works. Please note that Ronnie is 1 inch taller than Dorian.









 

I concur, this is sickening stuff from the master of denial. What's the point? Is anyone able to rescale them and show Dorian being crushed?

[LyricTenor]

 

[natural al]

you could say that about this whole thread not just those pics.

[NarcissisticDeity]

   I feel left out lol

[Ex Coelis]

ND's arguments are living on borrowed time - someone should help him

[sculpture]

ND's arguments are living on borrowed time - someone should help him

Gold.

[NarcissisticDeity]

ND:

Dorian is better than Ronnie.

Discuss.

I think you ended the discussion . that about sums it up . 

[LyricTenor]

haha, this debate was won by ND pages ago.

[pobrecito]

I just re-watched Dorian's posing routine from 1997. He looked absolutely horrendus and did not deserve to win. In fact, in my opinion, the only olympia titles Yates deserved were in 92 and 93. A torn bicep does not represent mr. olympia no matter how good your back is. Ronnie on the other hand I feel deserved more than two (98,99, 00, 03, 05)

[bicepsforyou]

Ripped

[NeoSeminole]

Just a friendly reminder why Suckmydick is a moron.

what's the point of big musles if you lack the separations to display them?

[Ronnie's] gut distension makes him lose the symmetry round flat out - just like it should have, at the 2003 Olympia. An appalling display for any bodybuilder, let alone to a standard-bearer.

In 1997, he had a torn triceps and biceps and his abdominal was distended - although not nearly as much as Coleman's in 2003/4

By way, these pics are from Dorian in 1997 and he still has a si-pack, a striated lower back and an incredible front lat spread. Too bad Ronnie doesen't look this good at over 270 lbs.

Ronnie in 2003 was great muscularity-wise, but he was not great overrall because his midsection was unacceptable and his body was completely unbalanced, especially the lower one.

[LyricTenor]

Afraid to post good pics of Dorian I see.  lol

[NarcissisticDeity]

I just re-watched Dorian's posing routine from 1997. He looked absolutely horrendus and did not deserve to win. In fact, in my opinion, the only olympia titles Yates deserved were in 92 and 93. A torn bicep does not represent mr. olympia no matter how good your back is. Ronnie on the other hand I feel deserved more than two (98,99, 00, 03, 05)

Wait a torn-bicep doesn't represent Mr Olympia but gynocomastia in 98/99 does? lol and looking like your pregnant does 01/02/03/04?   

[pumpster]

He looked absolutely horrendus and did not deserve to win. In fact, in my opinion, the only olympia titles Yates deserved were in 92 and 93.

The torn bicep doesn't excuse some of the other putrid appearances that are part of the over-rated hype. He just wasn't that good, and other guys like Wheeler deserved some of those wins, obviously.

[pumpster]

Afraid to post good pics of Dorian I see.

The good & bad ones are hard to discern. hahahaha

[NarcissisticDeity]

The torn bicep doesn't excuse some of the other putrid appearances that are part of the over-rated hype. He just wasn't that good, and other guys like Wheeler deserved some of those wins, obviously.

once again you've shown your ignorance. you make blanket statements and have nothing to offer up as to why and how and who should have beat him . when should have Flex beat Dorian? not in 93 . he was out in 94 in 95 he was way off and relegated to 8th , 96 he was slowly getting back to it he placed 4th and 97 the ninjas attacked him . so please elaborate on when exactly did Flex ' deserve ' some of those wins .

[NarcissisticDeity]

This represents the Mr Olympia? bitch-tits? 

[pumpster]

This represents the Mr Olympia? bitch-tits?

Speaking of bitches...he complains about the pics used then decides to focus on a particular year while he no longer has that and hasn't in most shows. Desperate.

[NarcissisticDeity]

Speaking of bitches...he complains about the pics used then decides to focus on a particular year while he no longer has that and hasn't in most shows. Desperate.

You'd know a bitch wouldn't you?    no he traded the gyno in for a pregnant belly . neither represent the Mr Olympia .

[LyricTenor]

Speaking of bitches...he complains about the pics used then decides to focus on a particular year while he no longer has that and hasn't in most shows. Desperate.

aww man pumpster you are filled with golden nuggets of comedy.  I can't believe this quote came from the guy who set the standard (even surpassing Hulkster) in showing the same pics from 1 single contest (94) over and over without discrimination.  Thats fine.   And you have trouble discerning a good pic of dorian from a bad?  That says much more about you then it does about dorian. 

[NarcissisticDeity]

aww man pumpster you are filled with golden nuggets of comedy.  I can't believe this quote came from the guy who set the standard (even surpassing Hulkster) in showing the same pics from 1 single contest (94) over and over without discrimination.  Thats fine.   And you have trouble discerning a good pic of dorian from a bad?  That says much more about you then it does about dorian. 

And when they do use a good picture of Dorian its scaled so he looks small next to Ronnie . the front double biceps comparision Dorian's waist is the same size and Ronnie's and Ronnie's calves are bigger than Dorians  and then they pat each other on the ass and say well done .