Hulkster I'm calling you an Asshole and Dorian kicks Ronnie's ass And you lost

[GoneAway]

As if 1600 pages were not enough to "solve" your "query". 

you expect me to go back and search through 1600 pages for one answer? like ive said before in this thread, there needs to be an official competition of sorts, as per a proper show, in judging these two physiques, since (as you so snotty suggested) the answer to this question has been brought up before... so why did hulkster repeat the statement if he's said it before to (presumably) the same people over and over? because this thread has no order and it's just a bunch of 'he said' 'she said' crap, whereby namecalling ensues in almost every post and it turns into a 'who is quoted as the best physique by X Bodybuilder/Historian' thread.

i think a truce would have been much better, as it's clear that neither party will ever agree. theyre too ignorant and 'wowed' by the physiques of their hero for that.

[Meso_z]

I think the thread should have a poll or smthing.

[GoneAway]

possible way to end it is for hulk and narc to find the best pics of their heroes in the mandatory poses that you would do in a bbing contest (including symmetry round), post them up here or give them to the mr getbig judges, and let them do their thing. then the result is what would determine who is the winner out of the two.

[SF1900]

Holy crap, this thread has A LOT of responses. I don't think I have seen any thread on any board I go on with this much responses!

[cht868]

Brutal fat and loose neck skin  ...you have the audacity to criticize Dorian and not this 

uh, where is the loose skin, just looks striated to me

[cht868]

lets just set a pole up and end this fucking thread

[NeoSeminole]

possible way to end it is for hulk and narc to find the best pics of their heroes in the mandatory poses that you would do in a bbing contest (including symmetry round), post them up here or give them to the mr getbig judges, and let them do their thing. then the result is what would determine who is the winner out of the two.

lets just set a pole up and end this fucking thread

both have already been done, and Dorian lost every time.

[Hulkster]

possible way to end it is for hulk and narc to find the best pics of their heroes in the mandatory poses that you would do in a bbing contest (including symmetry round), post them up here or give them to the mr getbig judges, and let them do their thing. then the result is what would determine who is the winner out of the two.

this has been done on other boards with excellent comparisons from Iceman.

and dorian got killed in the voting.

on some of the boards, Ronnie got 90% of the votes, even with hundreds of people voting..


the votes for dorian were quite famously "fixed" by someone on this thread, since they were unchanged for months at very few votes, then dorian's vote count went up by something like 2000 votes in two days...all of a sudden LOL convientiently after it was pointed out that hardly anyone thinks dorian is better at his best

LOL

[Hulkster]

hulkster, how about answering my question in the post just after your ronnie 99 vs. dorian 93 comparison, in page 1589. not hating, just want u to clarify which areas u think ronnie is more conditioned in and why.

its pretty obvious really.

ronnie`s chest is far more striated and dry, his delt-pec tie ins`are visible, dorians are invisible.

his arms from shoulder to forearm are far more defined and dry, dorians triceps are not even apparent.

for the back, both men display good detail in the rear lat spread (no smoothness here). However, ronnie has striations in the lower back, dorian has loose skin LOL

[England_1]

the votes for dorian were quite famously "fixed" by someone on this thread, since they were unchanged for months at very few votes, then dorian's vote count went up by something like 2000 votes in two days...all of a sudden LOL convientiently after it was pointed out that hardly anyone thinks dorian is better at his best

LOL

Bullshit. You are just pissed that Dorian won.

[Hulkster]

Bullshit. You are just pissed that Dorian won.

LOL you are fucking stupid if you think dorian's vote count magically went up by 2000 votes in two days after we were talking about how badly dorian got killed in this thread without it being fixed by you or another guy.

we are not that naive.

even ND admitted that something was up, but denied that it was him. and it probably wasn't.

it was either you or IceCold

ps even  with the extra votes, I still think dorian lost the polls LOL

[England_1]

LOL you are fucking stupid if you think dorian's vote count magically went up by 2000 votes in two days after we were talking about how badly dorian got killed in this thread without it being fixed by you or another guy.

we are not that naive.

even ND admitted that something was up, but denied that it was him. and it probably wasn't.

it was either you or IceCold

ps even  with the extra votes, I still think dorian lost the polls LOL

I'd like to see you deny the Ironage poll 

Of course you also probably think the teenie boppers on BB.com are as knowledgeable as the members of Ironage 

[Hulkster]

yes, the knowledge of the ironagers is well known, like their popular insistance that Larry Scott had a better physique than Ronnie Coleman in 98...

 

oh, and who could forget their comparisons using Ronnie in his worst ever shape (and dorian in the off season for that matter) against the best contest shots of their champions available..

you belong with that level of knowledge LOL

[Hulkster]

once again, we can clearly see that 99 Ronnie was in even better condition than dorian 93.

its just progress:

[Hulkster]

all the quotes from 93 are not going to change the fact that Ronnie was in even better condition than dorian was 6 years later:

more ripped, dry and striated everywhere, as usual when comparing dorian to Ronnie 99.

note to nuthuggers: this is NOT Ronnie 2003 LOL

[Hulkster]

even Ronnie 2001 AC was in better condition:

[Hulkster]

look at the incredible detail visible in ronnie that was absent in dorian. that is conditioning right there.

esp the delt/arm/forearm complex.

way way more conditioned, dry, striated and vascular.

[Hulkster]

check out the superior conditioning in the extended flexed quad of Ronnie over dorian.

its not even close in the conditioning department:

how much longer will the nuthuggers keep insisting what cannot be shown by looking at reality? (ie that dorian was in better condition than 99 ronnie)?

its getting stupid claiming something that is directly contradicted by real life.

[BillyGuns]

BIG SURPRISE!! YOU DIPSHITS ARE STILL ARGUING OVER RONNIE AND DORIAN. TWO HAS BEENS THAT LOOK  LIKE SHIT. YOU GUYS ARE PATHETIC. GET A LIFE WHY DON'T YOU. 

[GoneAway]

dorians triceps are not even apparent.

u cant see his triceps in the same way on his left arm because dorian is facing straight on and ronnie is shot from the side.

for the back, both men display good detail in the rear lat spread (no smoothness here). However, ronnie has striations in the lower back, dorian has loose skin LOL

true, but dorian also has much better separation between the teres major and latissimus dorsi.

[RocketSwitch625]

Notice how Sulkster keeps posting the craziest shots of Yates and claiming it wouldn't stand a chance against his hero at his best? He doesn't realise all he is doing is proving to everyone how good Yates really was. PWN£D. LOL

[Hulkster]

LOL its sad that you think those most musculars are 'good' or that dorian is in better condition than Ronnie 99 when real life shows he was not.

[RocketSwitch625]

LOL its sad that you think those most musculars are 'good' or that dorian is in better condition than Ronnie 99 when real life shows he was not.

If I'm sad for thinking that then so were the judges in 1993. You really are a prick. LOL

[IceCold]

LOL its sad that you think those most musculars are 'good' or that dorian is in better condition than Ronnie 99 when real life shows he was not.

real life would be that 93 is a legendary year that virtually all bbing fans know of.

(just like the youtbue description -"93 olympia - needs no introduction").

99 came and went like any other year.

in 93, yates changed bbing.

in 99, NOTHING was said about ronnie.

i'm still waiting for you to prove otherwise.

yates was still harder and dryer.  ronnie ALWAYS had more detial and striations than yates - eps. when they competed.  nothing happened.

hope this helps.

[Hulkster]

in 99, NOTHING was said about ronnie.

i'm still waiting for you to prove otherwise.

and I am waiting for you to explain how that matters at all when the visuals clearly show Ronnie was better- condition wise and physique wise.

 

you seem to think that you need a printed quote to 'verify' what the visuals already show all of us.

it doesn't work that way - in life, most things happen without being quoted in a magazine..