Please tell me how was I wrong?
easy.
you are wrong because Ronnie had a better physique at his peak using the conventional criteria than dorian ever did.
and this is easy visible with mountains and mountains of visual proof.
everyone can see this.
so should you:
Ronnie has better shape, more detail, equal size.
as has been said, Ronnie looks like a champion bodybuilder. Dorian, like a bricklaying construction worker..