I just saw the revise list. Whose that twink ahead of me -- monster tricep. Post a side by side comparison. I don't think he's carrying more muscle or is in better condition than I am. And move Dustin ahead of that alcoholic CalvinH.
Man that is a tough one, I think Calvin's got him on over all thickness but Dustin really has that nice flow about him so I could definitely go either way.
I think you should definitely be about 4 slots up, above Monster Triceps, Devilsmile, Backday and Sherief(which is a complete joke anyway, I mean that picture is like 12 years old

)
I put you SLIGHTLY above MuscleCenter who has you on mass but I think your overall leaness edges him out and below Di Vinci who might be just a little bit out of your reach mass wise plus he has some solid conditioning and overall shape (that side arm shot is sick!). That bro really has a visually "beach body" type physique that is hard to argue against so there is now reason to feel bad about being JUST below him overall.
So between Musclecenter and Di Vinci seems like a perfect fit for your physique, imo.
Yours is of an older fella who has paid his dues in the gym, keeps a low bf % and excellent taper and is still able to compete with the younger fellas at a very high level which is very admirable. Still kicking ass at an older age!