I'm confused, first you say A lot of people like this overly emotional and reactional nutjob are in decision making positions, and then you're telling others their too emotional and reactionary to be a decision maker because they want her fired.
Parsing the comments and changing the order makes it more difficult to give you a rational answer.
Bay is too emotional and reactionary. He feels the contract between programs and residents is one-sided and doesn't need to be honored in cases that become sensationalized.
My opinion is that they made an agreement to train her and are obligated to make reasonable attempts at remediating any shortcomings prior to ending a person's career.
She's an ass. Tons of people in have gotten multiple chances at fixing their mistakes in residency and life. It's people taking themselves too seriously who can sit in the ivory tower and judge.
Irony is some of the same people are advocates for poor, disenfranchised, learning disabled, special needs, and any other situation where offering some help or attending a charity event can let them feel smug. The second someone with social, educational parity has an issue it's "Off with their heads!", LOL! Did their compassion suddenly disappear or is a case of being full of shit? In most cases I believe "full of shit" is true and that most people are only compassionate to whatever extent it makes them feel better. The doctor is at the top of the food chain, people can only feel better if she crashes and burns.