stupid ? no ignorant yes and 99% of the people on this board alone are ignorant of how contests are judged and base everything solely on their personal preference that pool means Ronnie is a popular bodybuilding and he has man fans if you think this is some sort of proof you're right , you just met my expectations on what a majority of Coleman fans are 
You can lay out all the rules of judging and it is still going to be subjective.
They may agree that Yates is harder but that Coleman shows more definition, seperation
and striations. They may prefer Coleman's shape over Yates. They may say Coleman's
thighs are not in proportion to his calves and that Yates arms are not in proportion to his
torso. Just because you believe Yates meets that criteria better doesn't mean that someone
else is wrong because they see it a different way. I know you feel way more passionate about this than I
do and I am amazed at you and Hulkster's dedication to proving the other wrong.
As much as you feel you are right it comes down to the individuals subjective opinion
as who fits the judging criteria better.