Is it that Phil looks great at any body weight or is it that he is one of the few pros who is being honest about his weight? Other pros around his height would claim to be 20 pounds heavier despite not looking any bigger.
Come on......In the national ranks, people have to step on an official scale to make weight. Much like in wrestling. So, look at the weights of pros before they turned pro.
Bill Whilmore was weighing in the high 260's at weigh ins
Someone like Vic Martinez, who was a heavyweight, and looks AT LEAST 20lbs bigger than he was then, should have no problem claiming a weight of around 250lbs.
Someone like Jay who was near 250lbs when he turned pro, and is clearly MUCH larger now, should have no complaints claiming 270's.
Now, perhaps someone like Dexter, who was a light heavy when he turned pro would have a harder time claiming 230's, as he doesn't look nearly 40lbs heavier.
But, for hte most part the pro's claims are pretty accurate.
The Ironman has had official weigh ins, so those competitors should be cleared.
Phil just has the look to be a freak at any weight. Very few people have that look.